← All analysis
How do professionals look at DIS stock?

Disney: a 90% Buy panel, a hit ratio of 58%, and a stock priced 17% below its 52-week high

Revenue +6.5%. Earnings down 31% in the latest quarter. FY 2025 Financial Scorecard: 3 of 4 strong. P/E 16.52, Price/Book 1.65. DIS is 17% below its 52-week high and down 7% over the past year. 19 analysts: 90% Buy, 10% Hold, 0% Sell — average target $133.88 vs current $103.28. Implied upside +29.6%.

Educational content only — not financial advice. Always do your own research. Fundamentals from restnvest (SEC 10-K, 2025-11-13) · Analyst data from Anachart (2026-05-27)
streamingmedia-and-entertainmenttheme-parks
Three lenses on The Walt Disney Company. Are they aligned?
The business Strong
Financial health 3/4 · Revenue +6.5% · FCF margin 3.85% · ROIC 11%
The stock Caution
Valuation 2/4 · P/E 16.52x · 17% below 52-week high · Timing 2/3
The analysts Bullish
19 analysts · 90.48% Buy · 9.52% Hold · 0% Sell · Avg target $133.88 (+29.6% upside)
Bullish coverage at a 30% premium — and a historical hit rate that asks how much weight to give it
Analysts are 90% Buy with an average target of $133.88, implying +30% upside from the current $103.28. The FY 2025 10-K reads strong at 3 of 4 Financial Scorecard signals supportive. But the stock is down 7% over the past year, the most recent quarterly earnings fell 31%, and analysts have historically hit their DIS targets only 58% of the time — meaningfully below their accuracy on other names in this coverage set.
The case for owning Disney
What the business fundamentals say
Strong
From the 10-K filing · 2025-11-13
Investment thesis — DIS
Strong emphasis
Moderate
Strategic themes
Direct-to-Consumer StreamingContent Production and LicensingInternational ExpansionMerchandising and Licensing
Competitive moats
Brand PowerContent LibraryScale Economies
Market opportunity

Disney sells into the global market for entertainment, sports, and experiences. Direct-to-consumer streaming through Disney+ (132M subscribers) and Hulu (64M subscribers) is the primary growth vector, with ESPN's streaming transition adding sports as a parallel lane. The theme parks and cruise business contributes durable cash flow that few competitors can match. International expansion in streaming and parks is positioned as the multi-decade tailwind, though near-term subscriber growth has slowed in mature markets.

Value creation

Disney's value creation comes from monetising iconic IP across multiple channels — streaming, theatrical, parks, licensing, merchandise. The model produces a 12% profit margin and 11% return on equity. Free cash flow margin sits at 4%, reflecting heavy ongoing investment in streaming content and parks expansion. The dividend was reinstated after a pandemic suspension and now yields 1.5%, with a 20% payout ratio that leaves room for both buybacks and continued reinvestment. The most recent quarter showed earnings down 31% year over year, complicating the FY 2025 10-K's healthier picture.

Extracted from SEC 10-K. Full thesis on restnvest →
Stage 2 · Financial performance
Financial scorecard
3 of 4 strong
Growth quality
Scalable Growth
Profit quality
Cash-Backed Profits
Debt safety
Comfortable Coverage
Owner value quality
High Returns, Limited Reinvestment
Rev growth +6.5% · FCF margin 3.85% · ROIC 11%
Bottom line: 3 of 4 Financial Scorecard signals strong on the FY 2025 10-K. P/E 16.52, Price/Book 1.65 — reasonable. 90% Buy ratings, $134 avg target, 132M Disney+ subs, 64M Hulu subs, and an IP library with few peers.
versus
The case for caution
What the stock price and analysts say
Caution
Stage 3 · Valuation
Valuation scorecard
2 of 4 sensible
✗ Price discipline
Recovery Entry — 17% below 52-week high, trending up from below 200-day
✓ Price tag
Sensible — P/E 16.52, forward P/E 15.06
✓ Capital discipline
Sensible — restored dividend, modest payout ratio
✗ Doubling potential
Risky — limited upside math at the current growth rate
Stage 4 · Timing
Timing signals
2 of 3 supportive
Trend
Strengthening structure
Momentum
Mixed
Stretch
Neutral
Trend: Both highs and lows are improving — structure is supportive
Momentum: Short-term improving but long-term baseline flat — pressure gap narrowing
Stretch: RSI balanced, pressure flat — neither overbought nor oversold
Analyst conviction · Anachart · 2026-05-27
Where do analysts stand — and how much runway is left?

Y = price target. X = days remaining on call (negative = past expected hit window). Bubble size = Anachart Performance Score. Dashed vertical = the expected-hit boundary.

Buy
Hold
Sell
Upper-left · Fading signal
High target, window closing.
Upper-right · Most interesting
Bold call, plenty of runway.
Lower-left · Stale or wrong
Modest target, window closed.
Lower-right · Cautious coverage
Modest target, time left.

Chart shows 15 of 19 covering analysts. See all on Anachart →

Bottom line: Stock down 7% over 1 year while the S&P returned 28%. Most recent quarterly earnings -31% YoY. FCF margin only 4%. Historical analyst hit rate on DIS is 58% — below the 70–90% range seen on other large caps in this set.

The reconciliation

Disney presents a different shape from the other tickers in this set. The fundamental picture from the FY 2025 10-K is broadly positive — 3 of 4 Financial Scorecard signals strong, Scalable Growth, Cash-Backed Profits, Comfortable Coverage. The Valuation Scorecard is 2 of 4 sensible, with Price Discipline flagged Caution at 17% below the 52-week high and trending up from below the 200-day. P/E of 16.52 and Price/Book of 1.65 are unremarkable for a diversified media and experiences company. The 4% free cash flow margin is thin given heavy ongoing investment in streaming content and parks expansion. Two factors complicate the analyst case. First, the FY 2025 10-K was filed November 13, 2025, before the most recent quarterly report showed earnings down 31% YoY. The 'Scalable Growth' label captures the full-year picture, not the latest quarter. Second, the historical hit rate on DIS price targets is 57.9% — well below the 70%–95% range we see on other large caps in this set. The bullish camp argues the streaming business is finally a real earnings contributor, ESPN's direct-to-consumer transition opens a new revenue line, and parks remain the most durable cash flow in entertainment. The cautious view notes the stock is down 7% over the past year while the S&P returned 28%, and the recent quarterly miss may signal more pressure to come.

Sources
Fundamentals: restnvest — SEC 10-K, 2025-11-13. | Analysts: Anachart — 2026-05-27.
This is educational content only — not financial advice.